60 Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers That Aren’t Junk

1. Finger Puppets

These adorable finger puppets encourage storytelling and imaginative play. They are soft and perfect for little fingers. This set of 20 is easy to separate between siblings. After the egg hunt, they could also do a puppet swap, so everyone gets their favorite animal.

2. Mini Slinkies

These smiley slinkies bring back the nostalgic fun kids today will enjoy. This pack of 30 slinkies is great for an annual Easter egg hunt with lots of kids.

3. Bouncy Balls

For a timeless classic that is fun both indoors and outside, add some bouncy balls to your plastic eggs. This is a great option when you need a lot of Easter egg fillers. Kids will have fun swapping for their favorite color after the Easter hunt.

4. Jumping Frogs

Another good idea for a large group is these plastic jumping frogs. Kids press the backs of the frogs to watch them hop around.

5. Tiny Dinosaurs

These tiny dinosaurs are a must-have for dino lovers. This is a set of 12 different dinosaurs, making them perfect Easter egg stuffers for a single child. You may need slightly larger eggs to fit these fun Easter egg fillers.

If you’re worried about the dinos not fitting in your eggs, try these hatching dinosaur eggs. Just hide them along with all the other plastic Easter eggs for a special surprise.

6. Army Men

These classic toy soldiers are perfect for imaginative battles and strategic play. Kids can stage rescue missions or simply collect different poses.

7. Squishies

These soft, slow-rising, squishy toys are great for kids of all ages. They’re fun to squeeze and collect!

8. Hot Wheels Cars

Hot Wheel cars are a huge hit for non-candy Easter egg filler ideas. You might need larger eggs to hold the cars, but they are great for starting a collection or adding to an existing one.

9. Barbie Clothes

Barbie clothes are the perfect surprise for kids who love dressing up their Barbies. The great thing about these Easter egg stuffers is that when kids shake the eggs, they will sound and feel empty, so it will be a total surprise when they open them.

10. Mini Brands

Mini Brands were made for Easter eggs. Five surprises come in each ball, so break it open and place those surprises in the eggs.

There are so many different types of Mini Brands (foods, toys, fashion, Disney, etc) that you’re sure to find something your kid will love. Whether you add to their collection or start a new one, these small toys make good options for Easter morning.

11. Lego Sets

These sets of animal Legos are a great way to build a collection of unique characters. Separate pieces of each set into different eggs. Mark the eggs so you know which Legos belong to which set. After your hunt is over, kids can spend the afternoon assembling their animals.

12. Littlest Pet Shop Pets

Littlest Pet Shop Pets are tiny, adorable pets kids love collecting. This is another small toy that was made for Easter egg fillers.

13. Mini Play-Doh

Kids of all ages will love finding these mini Play-Doh jars in their Easter eggs. Older kids benefit from Play-Doh by encouraging creativity, while it helps little kids develop fine motor skills.

Related: Easter Gifts for Your Toddler

14. Small Stickers

These puffy stickers are perfect for decorating notebooks, water bottles, or craft projects. Cut the sheets apart to roll them into the eggs. This Easter sticker set includes stickers, stampers, and temporary tattoos, all themed for Easter.

15. Stampers

These small stampers offer a variety of fun designs, so they’re good for a few kids or even a larger group of children. These egg-shaped Easter-themed stampers work great as fillers or to hide them on their own.

16. Glow in the Dark Stars

Put these glowing stars on ceilings or walls for a special treat at bedtime. Use them in a neighborhood egg hunt to share with all the kids.

17. Stackable Crayons

These stackable crayons are great ideas for filling Easter eggs. Pull them apart and hide them in different eggs. Hide each crayon color in the same egg color and have kids find each color of the rainbow for a complete set of crayons. Or let the kids go wild, and they can trade crayons when they’re done.

18. Sticky Notes

These animal sticky notes are great for doodling or writing secret messages. Roll them and stuff them in your plastic eggs for a cute surprise.

19. Temporary Tattoos

These temporary tattoos are a mess-free, easy way for kids to express themselves with fun designs. There are enough tattoos here for a large group. Cut them apart and place a few in each egg. For even more fun, check out these glow-in-the-dark tattoos.

20. Washi Tape Rolls

These Washi tape rolls have cute, decorative patterns perfect for crafting or scrapbooking for older kids. Even little kids will like making fun tape patterns with these.

21. Beads for Bracelets

These beads for bracelet making are fun and colorful for creative kids. Kids can mix and match designs and colors to make a unique piece of jewelry.

22. Paint Pods

Paint pods are the perfect Easter egg fillers for creative kids. For a fun group activity, supply paper or art pads so the kids can create a work of art after the hunt.

23. Mini Bubbles

These mini bubble bottles fit perfectly inside plastic eggs and are great for continuing the outdoor fun on Easter morning.

24. Sidewalk Chalk

Hide this egg-shaped sidewalk chalk in your plastic eggs for an exciting reveal that younger children and big kids can use to create a driveway masterpiece.

25. Flower Seeds

Teach kids about gardening by hiding seed packets in your Easter eggs and enjoy watching your flowers grow all spring long.

26. Water Balloons

Surprise kids with a bunch of water balloons in their eggs. This is a great way to celebrate a warm spring day. Fill them immediately for instant outdoor fun. They can add so much fun to a neighborhood egg hunt.

Related: Fun Outdoor Easter Egg Hunt Ideas

27. Alphabet Magnets

Letter and number magnets help younger kids learn the alphabet while playing on the fridge or a magnetic board.

Related: Fun Easter Books Toddlers Will Love

28. Puzzle Pieces

The pieces in this mini-shaped puzzle are small enough to fit in Easter eggs and will give children a good challenge. You could always choose smaller puzzles for little children.

29. Math Dice

Math dice are a fun way to make math and learning numbers fun. These are good-sized dice, so you will need some jumbo eggs to be sure they fit.

30. Slap Bracelets

Slap bracelets are the classic toy that wraps around your wrist with a satisfying snap. Grab this pack of DIY slap bracelets so kids can create their own designs.

31. Mini Hair Clips

These mini hair clips are a stylish addition to your child’s hair accessory collection. They clip in easily and look great in either young kids or older children’s hair.

32. Light-Up Scrunchies

Regular hair ties are great, but these light-up scrunchies will be a big deal when they pop out of the Easter eggs.

33. Friendship Bracelets

Kids can collect or trade these cute friendship bracelets, making them fun Easter egg fillers they can enjoy all year.

34. Rings

For a fun, colorful accessory, grab this box of rings. Perfect for just one child or split between a few so they can swap.

35. Earrings

Earrings are a special little treasure for kids who love to accessorize. This set is perfect for kids with sensitive ears and offers a great selection. For kids without pierced ears, check out these stick-on earrings.

36. Mini Nail Polish

This mini nail polish set is great for kids who love to paint their nails. The colors are cute, stickers are included, and the paint is easy to remove.

37. Scented Lotion

These mini lotions are a fun way for kids to try light fragrances while keeping their hands moisturized.

38. Money

For a simple but exciting surprise, add coins or small bills as egg fillers that kids can choose to save or spend on a larger item. Dollar bills don’t make any noise when you shake the egg, so kids will be surprised, thinking that the egg is empty. This is a great way to start teaching kids about saving versus spending.

39. Mini Erasers

These small animal erasers are perfect for kids to take to school or to collect. Either way, they make great non-candy options.

40. Lip Balm

These flavored Lip Smackers are a fun way to keep lips moisturized while adding a sweet surprise to your kids’ Easter egg hunt.

41. Mini Flashlights

These mini flashlights make a cool and useful egg filler that kids will love to play with at night.

42. Tiny Animal Keychains

These tiny animal keychains are fun to collect or hang from a backpack. It’s a pack of 32 keychains, so there’s enough for a large egg hunt.

43. Character Band-Aids

Character Band-Aids are fun and practical. Just be sure your kids don’t run through them all in one day.

44. Sensory Rings

These quiet sensory rings are small and fun for sensory play or for kids with autism or anxiety. They are perfect for keeping hands busy without a noisy fidget toy.

45. Mini Stress Balls

These spiky stress balls are perfect for little hands to squeeze, helping with stress relief and fidgeting. They come in bold colors, making them an ideal sensory-friendly Easter egg surprise.

46. Mini Fidget Toys

Perfect for on-the-go fun, these quiet fidget toys help kids focus and relax without creating noisy distractions.

47. Stretchy Animals

These stretchy animals are fun sensory toys that stretch and bounce back into shape. Roll them in a circle and stuff them in the eggs, and they’ll pop out when opened.

48. Mini Fidget Spinners

These soccer ball fidget spinners provide endless spinning fun, helping kids stay focused and calm. Their size makes them perfect for Easter eggs and keeping them in your pocket.

49. Mini Pop Its

These Pop It keychains are tiny versions of the popular fidget toy, letting kids enjoy popping fun anywhere. They easily attach to backpacks and are fun to collect or trade.

50. Pop It Bracelets

Pop It bracelets make a fun, wearable fidget toy kids can take anywhere. The colorful designs are eye-catching and stylish.

51. Easter Egg Tokens

Easter egg tokens can be redeemed for bigger items that won’t fit in the eggs or fun experiences. This set includes a few blank eggs so you can create your own rewards.

52. Mini Wooden Crosses

These wooden crosses are a meaningful egg filler and are an excellent idea for a church Easter egg hunt. They’re small enough to carry in your pocket if you need a lift.

53. Small Plush Bunnies

These small plush bunnies are perfect for Easter-themed playtime and just the right size for little children.

54. Small Plush Chicks

These plush chicks make a cute and festive Easter-themed toy. See how many chicks your kids can hatch from their Easter eggs to win a larger prize.

55. Egg-Shaped Bath Bombs

These fun and fizzy egg-shaped bath bombs dissolve in water, releasing vibrant colors, soft scents, and a small toy surprise. They’re sure to make bathtime more exciting.

56. Homemade Coupons

Homemade coupons are the perfect way to give kids special privileges at home. These are great for older kids who aren’t interested in small toys. And you can personalize them any way you like.

57. Movie Ticket Vouchers

Whether you buy actual movie tickets or include a voucher that says, “Good for a Movie Day,” this is a special way to connect with your family. You could even buy snacks and a drink or make a day out of it and have lunch at a nice restaurant before the movie.

58. Travel Vouchers

If you are planning an upcoming family trip and want to make it a surprise, create some travel vouchers detailing the information about your trip.

59. Personalized Notes from the Easter Bunny

Including a note from the Easter Bunny adds a magical touch to your Easter morning. Create a scavenger egg hunt by hiding the letter in the first egg with clues to the next egg. Or use the scavenger hunt idea to lead them to the last egg with the letter and their Easter basket.

Related: Fun Easter Ideas for Little Kids

60. Puzzle Pieces to a Bigger Picture

Create your own puzzle to have kids work together to decode the picture. Whether it’s a large gift, a special trip, or a family photo, this is a unique experience for your little ones.

Just print out a picture and cut pieces into fun shapes to have kids reassemble once all the pieces are found.